Efficiency and Effectiveness Analysis of Village Financial Management (VFM) (Case Study Asahan Regency)

Bukit Buchori Siagian, Maryunani Maryunani, Rahmad Krishna Sakti, Dwi Budi Santoso


As an implementation of decentralized development, village financial management (VFM) is a financing model in a way to closer the needs of development at the village level. Theoretically, the successful objectives achievement of this authority delegation is if VFM can be done efficiently and effectively. This study aimed to analyze these efficiency and effectiveness of VFM and analyze factors inhibiting. The results showed that 1) VFM in Asahan district has not implemented both efficiently and effectively that shown from the weak implementation of both good governance principles and continuous improvement and, 2) Factors inhibiting the efficiency and effectiveness of VFM are, (i) lack of musrenbang transparency specifically the quality of information, access to information, the transparency mechanism of information and the level of information disclosure, (ii) lack of budgeting transparency, in particular the level of information disclosure, access to information and quality of information, (iii) lack of supervision transparency in particular the level of transparency, information quality and information access, (iv) the weak of oversight participation, especially the satisfaction level of participation and involve the community, and (v) lack of monitoring accountability in particular public complaints mechanism, access to the audit report and the responsibility structure.

Full Text:



Arikunto, Suharsimi, 2006. Research Procedure A Practice Approach, Jakarta, PT. Rineka Cipta.

Asian Development Bank, 2009, Good Governance. www.adb.go.id

Asni, Fauzi, 2013. Analysis of the Village Fund Allocation Management To Support Economic Independence Village On Siak, Dissertation University of Brawijaya, Malang.

Aziz, M.A.A., Rahman,H.A., Alam,M.M., Said,J., 2015. Enhancement of the Accountability of Public Sectors through Integrity System, Internal Control System and Leadership Practices: A Review Study. Procedia Economics and Finance 28, 163 – 169.

Barankay, Iwan & Lockwood, Ben. 2007, Decentralization and the productive efficiency of government: Evidence from Swiss cantons, Journal of Public Economics vol 91. Pp 1197–1218

Bauhr, M., Grimes, M., 2012. What is government transparency? Quality of Government Institute Working Paper (6), 822.

Bolívar, M.P.R., Navarro,A & Munoz, G.L.A., 2015. Governance, transparency and accountability:An international comparison. Journal of Policy Modeling 37, 136–174

Botes, L & Rensburg, V.D., 2000. Community participation in development: nine plagues and twelve commandments. Community Development Journal, 35, 41-58.

Boulding, C & Wampler, B., 2010. Voice, votes, and resources: evaluating the effect of participatory democracy on well-being. World Development, 38 (1), 125–135.

Cimpoerua, M. V & Cimpoeru,V, 2015. Budgetary Transparency – an Improving Factor for Corruption Control and Economic Performance. Procedia Economics and Finance 27, 579 – 586.

Coglianese, C., 2009. The transparency president? The Obama Administration and open government. Governance, 22 (4), 529−544.

Devaney, Laura, 2016. Good governance? Perceptions of accountability, transparency and effectiveness in Irish food risk governance, Food Policy 62, p 1–10

Drazkiewicz,A., Challies,E & Newig,J, 2015. Public participation and local environmental planning: Testing factors influencing decision quality and implementation in four case studies from Germany. Land Use Policy 46, 211–222

Dumairy, 1996. Indonesian economy. Publisher Erlangga, Jakarta.

Faguet, Jean Paul, 2014. Decentralization and Governance. World Development Vol. 53, pp. 2–13.

Florini, A., 2000. Does the invisible hand need a transparent glove? Proceedings of the 11th Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics. The World Bank, Washington, DC.

Goetz, A. M & Gaventa, J., 2001. Bringing citizen voice and client focus into service delivery. IDS Working Paper No. 138. Sussex: Institute of Development Studies.

Greiling, D & Spraul, K., 2010. Accountability and the challenges of information disclosure. Public Administration Quarterly, 338-377.

Halachmi, A & Greiling, D, 2013. Transparency, E-Government, and Accountability. Public Performance & Management Review, 36 (4), 562-584.

Harrison, Teresa M. dan Sayogo, Djoko Sigit, 2014. Transparency, participation, and accountability practices in open government: A comparative study Government Information Quarterly 31, 513–525.

Heald, D, 2003. Fiscal transparency: concepts, measurement and UK practice. Public Administration, 81 (4), 723-759.

Heller, P, 2001. Moving the state: The politics of democratic decentralization in Kerala, South Africa, and Porto Alegre. Politics & Society, 29 (1), 131–163.

Iyoha, F.O & Oyerinde,D, 2010. Accounting infrastructure and accountability in the management of public expenditure in developing countries: A focus on Nigeria. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 21, 361–373.

Kolstad, I & Wiig, A, 2009. Is transparency the key to reducing corruption in resource-rich countries? World Dev. 37 (3), 521–532.

Kopits, G., & Craig, J, 1998. Transparency in government operations, IMF occasional paper: 158

Krina, Loina, Lalolo, 2003. Indicators and Measurement Principles of Accountability, Transparency and Participation, Good Public Governance Secretariat, National Development Planning Agency, Jakarta.

Lestrelin,G., Bourgoin,J., Bouahom,B., Castella,J.C, 2011. Measuring participation: Case studies on village land use planning in northern Lao PDR. Applied Geography 31, 950-958.

Mogiliansky, A. L, 2015. Social accountability to contain corruption. Journal of Development Economics 116, 158–168.

Muhi Ali Napiah, 2011. http://alimuhi.staff.ipdn.ac.id/wp-content /uploads /2012/ 06/FENOMENA-PEMBANGUNAN-DESA.pdf, accessed, Marc 7th 2014.

Mukhopadhyay, C, 2015. A nested framework for transparency in Public Private Partnerships: Case studies in highway development projects in India. Progress in Planning xxx, xxx–xxx.

Musgrave, Richard & Peggy B. Musgrave. 1989. In the State Financial Theory and Practice. The fifth edition, translation. publisher Erlangga. Jakarta.

Nurudin, S.M., Hashim, R., Rahman, S., Zulkifli, N., Mohamed, A. S. P & Hamik, S.A., 2015. Public Participation Process at Local Government Administration: A case study of the Seremban municipal council Malaysia, Procedia, Social and Behavioral Sciences, 211, 505-512.

OECD, 2002. [online].Best Practices for Budget Transparency. Avaliable from http://www.oecd.org/dataoecd/33/13/1905258.pdf

Pagans, Monica Yanez, 2014. Bureaucratic Delay, Local-Level Monitoring, and Delivery of Small Infrastructure Projects: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Bolivia. World Development Vol. 59, pp. 394–407.

Government Regulation No. 72 Year 2005 on the village.

Regulation interior minister, number 37 of 2007 on Financial Management Guidelines village.

Quiles, F.J.A., Galera, A.N & Rodríguez, D.O, 2014 Factors influencing the transparency of sustainability information in regional governments: an empirical study. Journal of Cleaner Production 82, 179-191

Rubin, I., 1996. Budgeting for accountability: Municipal budgeting for the 1990s. Public Budgeting & Finance, 16, (2), 112-132.

Said, Jamaliah & Hidayah, N.B.J, 2014. Accountability in government linked companies: an empirical finding. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences 145, 294 – 299.

Santoso, Dwi Budi, 2013. Budget Decentralization and Economic Development Inequality Among Regions In East Java, Journal of Global Bussiness and Economics. Vol. 7 Isue 1 P. 85

Schroeter,R., Scheel,O., Renn,O & Schweizer P.J, 2016. Testing the value of public participation in Germany: Theory, operationalization and a case study on the evaluation of participation. Energy Research & Social Science 13,116–125

Sedmihradskaa, Lucie, 2015. Budget Transparency in Czech Local Government. Procedia Economics and Finance 25, 598 – 606.

Shin, Roy. 2001, Strategies For Economic Development Under Decentralization: A Transformation of The Political Economy, International Journal of Public Administration. Vol. 24 (10). Pp 1083-1142.

Shah, A., Ed, 2007. Participatory budgeting. Washington, DC: World Bank.

Shaoul,J., Stafford,A & Stapleton,P, 2012. Accountability and corporate governance of public private partnerships. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 23, 213– 229.

Singh, Jagdeep & Singh, Harwinder, 2015. Continuous Improvement Philosophy – Literature Review And Directions, Benchmarking: An International Journal, Vol.22 No.1.pp. 75-119.

Speer, Johanna, 2012. Participatory Governance Reform: A Good Strategy for Increasing Government Responsiveness and Improving Public Services? World Development Vol. 40 No 12, pp. 2379–2398.

Sukmadilaga, Citra, Pratama, Arie, Mulyani, Sri, 2015. Good Governance Implementation In Public Sector: Exploratory Analysis of Government Financial Statements Disclosures Across ASEAN Countries. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 211 pp. 513 – 518.

Tosun, C, 2000. Limits to community participation in the tourism development process in developing countries. Tourism Management, 21, 613-633.

Law No. 32 Year 2004 on Regional Government,

Law No. 25 of 2004 on National Development Planning System.

Law No. 8 of 2005 Concerning Determination of Government Regulation in Lieu of Law No. 3 of 2005 on the Amendment of Law Number 32 Year 2004 on Regional Government Become Law.

Vishwanath, T & Kaufmann, D, 1999. Towards transparency in finance and governance. World Bank Working Paper. http://ideas.repec.org/e/pka21.html (diakses Maret 2016).

Wampler, B., 2004. Expanding Accountability Through Participatory Institution: Mayor, Citizen and Budgeting In Three Brazilian Municipalities, In:Latin America Politics&Society, 46 (2), pp.73-99.

Wellens, Lore & Jegers, Marc, 2014. Beneficiary participation as an instrument of downward accountability: A multiple case study. European Management Journal 32, 938–949

Williams, Andrew, 2015. A global index of information transparency and accountability. Journal of Comparative Economics 43, 804–824.

World Bank Report, 2005. Indonesia: Local Government Financial Management A Measurement Framework.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21776/ub.ijleg.2016.002.02.5


  • There are currently no refbacks.